March 18, 2009

"The Mysterious Benedict Society" by Trenton Lee Stewart

Yes, more young adult books from me!

The Mysterious Benedict Society by Trenton Lee Stewart (ISBN 0-316-00395-6) was actually recommended to me by my 12-year-old son. We have fun reading the same books so that we can talk about them, and this will be no exception.

The story focuses on four parentless children recruited to infiltrate a school that is using children to control minds. It uses the common YA themes -- kids who are special and underappreciated, ongoing humor, and the like. The children are found by Mr. Benedict through a very special test, one advertised with the enticing ad "Are you a gifted child looking for special opportunities?"

However, the book is good fare for the thinking reader. The story is almost all problem-solving, though done in several ways. The test to join the team includes several puzzles, the mission itself is mostly creative problem-solving, and the only help that the heroes can get from their patron, Mr. Benedict, is in the form of riddles.

Completing their mission requires falling back on information from the beginning of the story, and it requires that the four children work together, even when the don't want to. One character in particular is thought of as the least important member of the team, but the others remember the advice from Mr. Benedict that her particular skills might prove to be indispensible. They do, hilariously.

As with other of my favorite YA novels, I'd say that this appeals most to the somewhat-brainy kids. At nearly 500 pages, it's not a light read for a lot of kids ... it has a specific target audience, and it is a good story for them.

Although it's an adventure book, there is little violence. Even as the story climaxes, the only person hit by one of the heroes is the victim of a falling pail (though it does happen to be full of water and is descrbed as being as heavy as a bowling ball).

The story teases the reader with information. Morse Code, for example, is a prominent part of the story, and it's made clear that no one knows Morse Code anymore. Except, of course, the heroes. Even the villains don't know Morse Code. The smartest of them becomes suspicious of a coded message, but that's it.

Therefore, this book presents its readers with a golden opportunity to learn something special and unique to themselves. It doesn't teach Morse Code or much of the other information not strictly vital to the plot, but it invites kids to learn it.

A little bonus for learning Morse Code does exist, though ... A note in the back of the book (purportedly handwritten by Mr. Benedict) states that people have asked his first name. You can find that name if you use your Morse Code, and find where it's written.

I heartily recommend this book for advanced middle-school readers. My son, in 7th grade, loved it. It might lose appeal once the reader is high-school-aged, since the characters are younger, so this really is targeting the advanced readers. (Might I add a hearty "Hurrah!" to the author for doing that, as well!)

It's not a bad read for adults, either. I greatly enjoyed it. If you're an adult whose favorite TV spy is MacGyver, this might well be appealing. Stewart did a good job of presenting some serious issues to the kids and letting them deal with them.

One final note -- The quotations on the book didn't do it justice. The book is compared to the writings of Roald Dahl, Lemony Snicket, and J. K. Rowling. I suppose that this is to draw much-deserved attention, but I would argue that The Mysterious Benedict Society carves its own niche and owns it.

One of those quotes, though, did hit the nail on the head. The quote from Horn Book states that it's, "Real flashlight-under-the-bedclothes material." That it is.

This book richly deserves every one of its five stars out of five.


  1. Wickle,
    Thanks for posting this. I have enjoyed the books that you recommended in the past. I will have to get my hands on a copy of this.

  2. I just put this book on hold at the library and noticed that there is a second one that was released in 2008. Have you read that one or heard of it?

  3. Glad to know that someone is writing good, clean material for the YA set! I think that I would like this book myself.

  4. These books are totally awesome! Are you going to write another Benedict Society Book? It kind of seems like it because Mr. Curtain got away in the second book.(the perilous journey) PLEASE PLEASE PLEASE WRITE ANOTHER BENEDICT SOCIETY BOOK!!! I CANT GET ENOUGH!!!

  5. I LOVED this book and am trying to make my mom buy me the second one.I thought it was a wonderfull book and read it over and over again!5 stars out of 5!!

  6. The Mysterious Benedict Society is like the BEST book if I could read something every single day i'd read this book and now there are going to be way more (2) Mysterious Benedict societys one called The Mysterious Benedict Society and Perilous Journey and the other The Mysterious Benedict Society and the Prisoners Dilemma! YAHOO!

  7. Same here! This is my favorite author in the whole world! I hope he can write more Mysterious Benedict Society books soon!

  8. i loved this book. i just finished the Third.Awesome!

  9. I have read so many articles or reviews concerning the blogger lovers but this
    post is in fact a fastidious piece of writing, keep it

    Here is my web page site

  10. Persuade a partner, spouse or friend to lose weight with you.
    All the best to you and hope you achieve your dream of looking better
    and staying healthier. This diet loss is also based on your eating habits as well.

    Also visit my web page ... low carb diet side effects

  11. Another way of looking at this is to see that gardens and garden accents
    provide the power to transform one’s mood and one’s life.
    With just a little bit of planning you can find
    some wonderful accessories to decorate your backyard, porch,
    or patio for the fall season. You can make an intricate system or simply
    use an inexpensive rock fountain.

    Also visit my web site :: herb patio garden ideas

  12. Hi there, I log on to your blog regularly.
    Your story-telling style is witty, keep doing what you're doing!

    Here is my web blog :: adiphene facts

  13. Envision cuddling up within your livingroom watching your favored Xmas film before a warm glow out of your fireplace.
    In case your family tradition is to hang stockings in residence,
    then you can sew the identify of each family member about the
    stocking to increase the excitement in youngsters.
    Make a hole within the ball from where you can hang a ribbon to create the ornaments.

    Review my weblog homemade christmas decorations plans

  14. I'll right away grab your rss as I can't to find your email
    subscription link or e-newsletter service. Do you have any?
    Please let me recognize so that I could subscribe. Thanks.

    my webpage ...

  15. The table where it is to be placed should also be decorated as per the other decors used in the ceremony.
    Choosing the right cake should be meticulously
    done. Although you are working in the heat of the oven,
    the snacks you can create are enough to cool you off while enjoying the process of creating deserts yourself.

    Here is my webpage ... marble cheese cake decoration

  16. Beds for children especially interested in maritime things would do well to be bought from a nautical
    furniture store, and they work well in an ocean themed room.
    With that in mind, the following is a step-by-step method of
    how you can focus your baby nursery d. A set of three focus lights hanging from the ceiling could
    give your bathroom that extra special look reserved only for the best
    in its class.

    Here is my web page computer and study table design

  17. Hola! I've been following your website for some time now and finally got the bravery to go ahead and give you a shout out from Atascocita Tx! Just wanted to tell you keep up the great work!

    Feel free to visit my web page: click here


Thanks for joining our discussion of this book!

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...
Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...