Showing posts with label Trudy's Promise. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Trudy's Promise. Show all posts

October 23, 2009

The Kommandant's Girl by Pam Jenoff

I have actually been reading quite a bit lately, but nothing really inspired me to write a review until now.

I began reading this just after finishing Breaking Dawn, which was un-put-downable. Usually after a book like that, the rebound book is like having a "fun size" box of milk duds for dessert after an incomparable gourmet meal (although in general I consider the Twilight saga to be more like a tub of bon bons than any other food). Not this time. I read Breaking Dawn over two days. I read The Kommandant's Girl over about a six hour period, and it's only about 300 pages shorter. Yes, only.

The Kommandant's Girl is the story of Emma, a young married Jewish woman in Poland at the start of WWII. When Germany invades, her politically outspoken husband is forced to go underground. For her own protection, Emma assumes a new identity and has to pretend to be an unmarried, orphaned schoolteacher. When the intimidating Nazi Kommandant offers her a job in his office, Emma is terrified but also recognizes the opportunity to spy for the resistance and thereby help her husband. Her espionage takes her further into areas of danger and betrayal than she ever could have dreamed, and she must come to grips with her attraction to a man responsible for the horrible deaths of many of her friends and neighbors.

I've read books with similar plots and settings, and those that have been around The Book Nook for awhile will recognize parallels to Trudy's Promise. But this book has something more. The author, Pam Jenoff, is an expert on Poland and the Holocaust. Unlike many writers who are intrigued by such subject matter, Jenoff doesn't need to rely on sentimentality or conjecture to give her work poignancy. She simply writes the story as it could have happened, based on real Historical events, with a sincerity and accuracy that requires no frills. So this book is more raw and more gripping, in my opinion, than similar books I've read in the past.

I highly recommend this for anyone interested in this time period, as well as anyone who just likes a book that will keep them enthralled to the very end.

June 22, 2008

Book Discussion: Trudy's Promise

Hopefully by now you all have been able to read and finish the book! Like Marie said last month, I do not want to hijack the discussion, so I will simply post the discussion questions now and jump in once the discussion has started.

However, I can tell you that I chose the book for two reasons:

1. I really enjoy reading books that take place in Europe during this time period.

2. I enjoyed the last book I read by Marcia Preston (The Butterfly House) and was excited to read this one.

So now, onto the questions:

1. Did you find the book interesting? Why or why not? Did it exceed your expectations? Or did it not live up to your expectations?

2. Did you find the story believable? Why or why not?

3. Did you find the characters believable? Who was your favorite/least favorite?

4. Were you able to relate to the main character, Trudy? Would you have made the same choices she did, or would you have done something different?

5. What do you think about Kruger?

6. What did you think about the story once she came to America? Was it a believable chain of events? Were there any parts in particular that you thought did not "fit" with the rest of the story?

7. Were you surprised when Marcia Preston worked JFK's assassination into the story? Why do you think she did that?

8. Do you remember what was going on in your life when the Berlin Wall fell?

9. Is there something else about the book you want to bring up?

And please don't forget to email me your questions for Marcia Preston!! Email me at jdyrholm {at} comcast {dot} net!! I'll compile them and send them off to Marica Preson after the 25th.

May 31, 2008

Discuss Trudy's Promise with Marcia Preston!

This month we have the special opportunity to actually discuss our monthly book reading with the author herself! Join us during the month of June for our reading of Trudy's Promise by Marcia Preston, and after reading it, we will be able to share our thoughts and questions with Ms. Preston through emails.

However, we are on a sort of tight schedule, as she will be out of the country starting June 15. I know it is kinda last minute, but I don't want to miss out on such a great opportunity!

If you would like to join our reading, but won't be able to do it before the 15th, let us know, and perhaps we can have a "Part 2" discussion at another date.

Curious about the book? Here's the summary from the back cover:

An act of desperation divides a mother and her child. Only an act of faith can reunite them.

Trudy Hulst has no idea if her husband survived his attempted escape past the newly constructed Berlin Wall. But she knows too well the consequences of his actions. Now branded the wife of a defector, she faces a life in prison. With no real choice, she is forced to follow, praying she can find a way to claim their child once she's in West Berlin.

Trudy survives a harrowing break for freedom...only to learn her husband was shot during his escape. Terribly alone, she wanders the wall like a ghost, living for brief glimpses of her son, now out of reach behind barbed wire and armed soldiers. Desperate to regain her child, Trudy begins a journey that leads her to America, where she continues an odyssey of hope to find her son.


Another book of Ms. Preston's that we have reviewed is Butterfly House.
Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...
Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...