Showing posts with label western. Show all posts
Showing posts with label western. Show all posts

May 25, 2009

Sarah's Quilt by Nancy E. Turner

I'm happy to report that this sequel to These Is My Words was not a disappointment. The story of frontier woman Sarah Agnes Prine continues with Sarah living on her ranch outside of Tucson in a time of drought, facing an interesting assortment of outlaws and relatives and marriage proposals.

In a way this book is better than its predecessor, and in others it isn't as good. Turner's writing has matured, and yet she seems to run out of plot ideas. There is a plot, or a series of plots, but they seem to mainly be there just to give the book a raison d'etre. Really the book is about day to day life on a ranch run by a paradoxical yet admirable woman, and that alone is interesting enough to offset the plot weaknesses. My favorite bit of plot involves a long lost nephew that comes to live on the ranch, with the mistaken impression that he actually owns it, and the desire to be an outlaw. The best thing about these books for me, on a personal note, is that I find Sarah's character inspiring. She seems more real than most live people I come across, and she has a strength and fearlessness that I aspire to.

This book also stands alone quite well. It isn't necessary to read These Is My Words first to enjoy it, although I do recommend doing that just because it's such a great book. I hope Turner writes another in this series. She doesn't leave anything hanging, but I'd love to visit Sarah again.

May 9, 2009

These Is My Words by Nancy E. Turner

These Is My Words is an account of fictional pioneer woman Sarah Agnes Prine in the Arizona Territories. Written like a diary, it starts when she is 17 on the trail with her family from Arizona to Texas, and ends when she is in her mid-30's (to be continued in a sequel called Sarah's Quilt).

Sarah is like a combination between Scarlet O'Hara, Annie Oakley, and Sarah Plain and Tall. She's a crack shot and doesn't think twice about taking a life (or two or three) if family or friends are threatened. She's a very hard worker and craves an education more than anything. But she also wants to be a real lady, and struggles to fit that bill while doing the things necessary to survive in a lawless wilderness.

This book was amazing. I really came to love Sarah and many of the other characters. And this is one of those rare gems in which the romance really tugs at you. It seems like Turner wanted to see what would happen if Scarlet and Rhett were Western characters instead of Southern (although I couldn't stand Scarlet, Sarah is much more likable). In fact the more I think about it, the more parallels I see.

This book was impossible to put down. It's not a skinny book, but I read it in less than a day and immediately put Sarah's Quilt on hold at the library. I hope the sequel isn't a disappointment as so many sequels are.

March 23, 2009

Etta by Gerald Koplan


Not much is known about the legendary Etta Place who ran with the Outlaw bank robbing Hole- in-the-wall gang at the turn of the century. Where the historical record leaves off, Gerald Koplan steps in telling Etta’s imagined and incredible life story in his debut novel, Etta. Etta begins the story as a tom-boy debutante, lovely even though she prefers horseback riding and shooting to the tedium of parties. When her dad commits suicide, leaving her in financial ruin and threatened by some of his shadier financiers, Etta escapes west. On the edge of civilization she unexpectedly finds fulfillment and love in the unlikeliest of places.

As expected, the villains are dastardly, the heroines sweet, and our outlaws are gentlemen. The novel is told through diary entries, first person narration from several of the characters, fictional newspaper clippings, letters etc… This structure is as enjoyable as it is effective. The only caveat is beginning the book with an obituary, disclosing Etta was 80 at death which negates much of the suspense Koplan subsequently works so hard to build. To his credit however he does establish a strong female voice in Etta, and despite knowing the conclusion you will want to sort out the details of her journey.

The author admits in his notes that beyond fictionalizing some actual historical figures the bulk of his tale is not grounded in fact. If you are seeking a factual re-telling of the female outlaw or the hole in the wall gang this is not your book. However Etta expertly takes aim and is sure to captivate Historical Fiction and Western fans alike.


Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...
Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...