April 30, 2009

Bel Canto by Ann Patchett

Wow.

I could just leave it at that, but I think you probably expect something in the way of an explanation, eh?

Bel Canto is the story of a hostage situation in an unnamed Latin American country. This is not a crime novel. There is no gritty tragic detective trying to save the day or anything of the kind. The story is not in the crime itself, but in the situation it creates. 200 fabulously wealthy and famous people from around the world have gathered at the Vice President's home for a private concert of great opera star Roxane Coss. There are diplomats and corporate moguls, as well as a translator accompanying his boss and an opera loving priest who was allowed to listen from the kitchen. As the concert ends, suddenly the lights go out and a small army of rebels descends from the air conditioning vents. A standoff follows.

So what happens when a crowd of rich and influential people is forced into close quarters with a pack of teenagers from the jungle for an extended period of time? Again, not what you'd expect.

There are so many beautiful things about this novel. The premise in and of itself is elegant. But there's more. This book is, as people like to say, multi-layered. But it's not layered with the precise and definitive textures of an onion or even a parfait. It's more like a fine chocolate, with so many things to appreciate: the depth of flavor, the sweetness, the bitterness, the texture, the way it melts on your tongue, the aftertaste, the scent.

In the first place there is the writing. I'm from the Stein / Hemingway school of thought. A word is a very pure thing and ought not to be used carelessly. It's easy to see when a writer not only chooses her words with care and taste and precision, but when she really loved that word and savored it on her tongue. That's what poetry is supposed to be, a boiling down of language, a story in a few potent words. And that's the way Patchett writes. Don't misunderstand; she's not one of those horribly annoying people that uses melodramatic adjectives in place of sentences. Rather her sentences are composed of only the most perfect words; nothing more and nothing less.

Then you have her character development. The way the novel begins with a quick sketch of the crowd and its major players is the way many novels simply continue without further development. But Patchett keeps going, gracefully, diving a little deeper each time before letting us up for air. You really get to know and love the characters, in an easy organic fashion.

Then you have the situations she sets up. Usually in a book that involves hostages and terrorists there will simply be a lot of struggling with ropes and halted conversations between clenched teeth about escape routes and weaponry. Patchett is much more realistic. How will these people interact as they prepare meals, wait to use the bathroom, watch television together? Most writers skip over these scenarios, wanting to get at what they see as the meat: escape, rebellion, fighting! But Patchett's drama exists in these very spaces. And it is in those spaces where people fall in love.

And then there's the linguistics. The guests at this party are from all over the world. There are Russians, Germans, Japanese, French, Spanish, Dutch, American, and more. The terrorists themselves speak a local language and only a smattering of Spanish. Enter Gen, the lone translator, who is caught in the middle of negotiations, requests to use the facilities, declarations of love. It's a study of how people can communicate with and without the use of spoken language, what language can and cannot do for us, and more universal languages that transcend words, like love and food and music.

Music! Everyone listens to it, but I wonder how many people really love it. A lot of people casually say they love music, but does that mean listening to the radio on the way to work, or does it mean laying on the grass, tears rolling helplessly down your face as the vibrations of it radiate through you? It's this second kind of love we see in this book. Roxane Coss sings in several different languages that she herself does not speak, but the words don't matter. It's the language of the music itself that resonates and enraptures the hostages and captors. If you've never heard a live performance of orchestra or opera, you may not understand this. Believe me, it is not the same stuff you hear from a speaker. And it's even more so to anyone who has ever played an instrument. The characters' love and awe of Coss' music is transferred to Coss herself, who enjoys attentions no hostage before has ever dreamed of.

There's only one thing I didn't like about this book; then ending. Not just because it was over, which was a very sad event, but the ending just didn't seem to mesh with the rest of the book. It was too final, too decisive, and a little nonsensical.

Even bearing that in mind, I would give this book a thousand stars if I could.

April 29, 2009

The Shape of Mercy by Susan Meissner


The Shape of Mercy’s, Lauren, is the quiet introvert as in she doesn’t have any friends that she isn’t related to. She is forever trying to make up for the fact that she isn’t the son her father wanted. So she does everything her family does not expect in an attempt to forge her own path in life. A literature major in college, Lauren is near obsessed with proving that she isn’t a rich snob, so she takes an odd job—transcribing a diary of an accused Salem witch. While earning her spending money she discovers kindred spirits in her employer, Abigail, a wealthy recluse and the diary’s doomed author, Mercy. Learning from the past while on the cusp of her future, Lauren questions her destiny.

Susan Meissner recently spoke about this book, and she relayed that this book is about the individual power everyone has to effect their own and other’s circumstances. When reading the book, the reader understands that it’s never too late to take an action towards improving our world. This message may be why the book is classified as Christian Fiction, not detracting from that message, but this novel could have just as easily been branded Women’s or Historical Fiction. The story transcends genre and becomes simply a great read as good a recommendation to your Grandmother as it is to pre-teens.

The book is well shaped with endearing characters that are near impossible to resist. Mercy’s fate, Abagail’s life, and Lauren’s preconceptions are all revealed slowly which builds the novel’s suspense layer by layer. This novel is at times syrupy sweet and sentimental but always satisfying. If you loved, THE HERETIC’S DAUGHTER by Kathleen Kent or DELIVERANCE DANE by Katherine Howe, you’re sure to enjoy Meissner’s Salem interpretation.


April 28, 2009

Fables: Legends in Exile

I checked out Fables: Legends in Exile at the recommendation of WhatACard. As you all know, I tend to read far and wide, but I had not yet dipped in the graphic novel pool (is that mixing metaphors? if so, sorry).

I eagerly picked up this book because I am always interested in new takes on classic stories/characters/themes. The Fables series is based on the premise that fairy tale characters are exiled in New York. There is an underground community there, because they have to keep their true identities a secret. The plot of this one focuses on the myster of Rose Red's apparent death.

To be frank, I wasn't impressed. With a graphic novel, almost all the writing is done through dialogue, and the dialogue is poor. The plot and drawing is all fine, I guess, but in my opinion (as if the rest of the review isn't), a book--even if it's a graphic novel--is only as good as its writing. The most creative idea can be ruined by poor word choice, unpicturesque language, or wooden dialogue (though I wouldn't go so far as to say the dialogue in this case was wooden, just uninspiring).

With that, I wouldn't recommend this to someone unless they're already a fan of graphic novels, and if that's the case, they've surely already heard of it anyway, so there's no need.


April 27, 2009

Shadows Still Remain by Peter de Jonge




In Shadows Still Remain Peter de Jonge (as in the frequent James Patterson co-author) creates O’Hara a beautiful, rash and ambitious detective. O’Hara “catches” her first murder case and is determined to work it so much so that she breaks all the rules of professionalism and police protocol. As she learns more about the victim, Franseca Pena, “the undisputed star…whose approval and messy snorts of laughter the others vie for”, each new clue only begets more questions. Out of her league and damaging her career, O’Hara doggedly pursues the only avenue of redemption—solving her case.

Peter de Jonge unsurprising reads much like James Patterson. You’ll find the same page turning elements and suspenseful drama amongst colorful descriptions like, “slushy rain slobbers all over the roof, and O’Hara tracks a fat brown droplet down the windshield.” De Jonge however has gone darker and delivers a better than average police procedural story. If you novelized a Law and Order SVU script, you’d have the gist. The book is loaded with surprises and is a tough to solve who done it. The title is apt, as it leaves the reader with many questions and unresolved story lines, and one can only conclude that this may be the beginning of an exciting series.

So Brave, Young & Handsome by Leif Enger

This is Leif Enger's second book. His first, Peace Like a River, would be a hard act to follow as it was a practically perfect book. I enjoyed So Brave, Young and Handsome: A Novel, but I didn't love it.



Monte Beckett is a one-shot author. He wrote one best-selling book, quit his day-job at the post office and then flailed about. He is the sort of man I do not like, a man who lets life circumstances form his choices, as opposed to making choices that form his life circumstances. Fortunately for him, he married a woman not like me at all.

The book opens with Monte notices a man floating past him on the river. Though not immediately, Monte joins the man on his venture. His new companion is an outlaw, trying to go make amends with an abandoned wife before the law catches up with him.

Twas a good, though not great, read. I'd recommend putting it on hold at the library rather than running into town to purchase it. I'm sorry Mr. Enger. I loved Peace Like a River so much that I feel sad to not be able to rave over this one.

~Suzanne

April 22, 2009

Redemption Series by Karen Kingsbury

The best TV shows are the ones that end with you wanting to know what happens next. The ones that you season pass on your TiVo because you don't want to miss any part of the storyline. The ones where each episode leads into the next and is connected to all of the ones that came before it. Those are my favorite kind of shows.

So it's no surprise, I'm a sucker for any books that are part of a series. I love that by the end of a good series each of the characters is developed so thoroughly that I feel like I know them personally. And I'm sad to see them go.

Two years ago I did a giveaway on my blog and asked readers for book recommendations. One of the top recommendations was the book Redemption by Karen Kingsbury. I had no idea when I bought it that it was part of a five-book series. I just finished reading the fifth and final book of the series and wanted to let everyone know about these great books. I used Redemption in one of Fluent Brittish's book swaps, and everyone that read it loved the book.

So here I am taking that recommendation and passing it on to you. Karen Kingsbury's Redemption series is about people like you and me. It's about a family that goes through trials, struggles, and hardships. About individuals that sometimes forget their faith but always eventually come back around. About relationships between friends, family, lovers, neighbors, and strangers. It's about life. Life as I know it and life as you know it. And I recommend this book to anyone who is looking for a way to remember that no matter what happens, no matter how bad it gets, it will always be okay.

So if you're looking for a good book, I've got five for you. Redemption, Remember, Return, Rejoice, and Reunion.

And if anyone feels like buying me the next series- Firstborn by Karen Kingsbury, I like new books. And gifts.

Faith and Honor by Robin Maderich

One of the reviews on the back of Faith and Honor says, "...the right mix: history, romance, sex..." That pretty much perfectly describes the book for me. This book was one of those that I just couldn't put down from the minute I picked it up. The story is very Romeo and Julietesque, which is a story line that always sucks me in. But rather than being lovers from separate families, they are lovers on different sides of the Revolutionary War.

Faith Ashley and Fletcher Irons are perfect for each other. Other than the fact that Faith is helping the colonials smuggle firearms out of Boston and Fletcher is trying to catch the people doing the smuggling. But they are destined for each other and of course fall easily in love quickly after meeting. The book is about trying to maintain their relationship in the midst of a battle greater than either of them.

Maderich develops her characters wonderfully, and you feel for the couple as they try to prove that love can beat all odds. They quickly find that it can't. I'm not sure how historically correct (only because I don't know a whole lot about it) the book is about the Revolutionary War and the comings and goings of Boston at the time, but I felt like I was in a different time than my own while reading this novel. The story is somehow modern even though it's set in a different era, and I loved almost every minute of reading it. I recommend it to anyone that enjoys a good Romeo and Juliet story and/or historical romance novel.

Redeeming Love by Francine Rivers

I'm not a fan of most "Christian" fiction, particularly that of a romantic nature. It seems like the identification with the Savior of the world can be some sort of excuse for not using beautiful language or intriguing plot choices. That said, I have a bit of a weakness for this book.

Redeeming Love is the story of Hosea placed in early 1850s California, in a time of greed and treasure-seeking. After being sold into prostitution at a young age, Angel is a high-dollar prostitute in the mining town of Paradise. Michael rescues her, but Angel certainly isn't the most appreciative damsel in distress, seeking to repay Michael through hard work before escaping to get back into the lifestyle she hates.

While I enjoy this book, I don't think it's for everyone. If you're predisposed to dislike this type of book, stay away. However, if Christian fiction of the romantic persuasion is a genre you're interested in trying, I think this is the cream of the crop.


April 21, 2009

The Mysterious Benedict Society and the Perilous Journey by Trinton Lee Stewart

Wickle and son introduced me to The Mysterious Benedict Society. After reading the first one I couldn't wait to read the second book entitled The Mysterious Benedict Society and the Perilous Journey.

The second book did not disappoint. In fact, in some ways I thought it was better than the first one. For example, Constance is less annoying. (Whether because she is more mature or I just understand her better, I am unsure.) And in this story they all have families instead of being all alone in the world.

Like the first book, Perilous Journey showcases how giftedness comes in various forms and sizes. We are shown that bravery isn't being fearless. Love is shown as requiring personal sacrifice.

The only thing that I found annoying was that there wasn't more violence at the end. But I suppose that you can't have kids blowing people up in a book meant for kids. And I suppose if all the villains were dead, there wouldn't be a book three. (Its coming out in October 2009. :) I already have it on my wishlist.)

I think this series will appeal to rather intellectual kids (and grownups that don't think kidlit is beneath them). There is lots of clue finding and problem solving (though less Morse code) just like in the first book. It is rather a long book, but well worth every page.

I give this book 5 stars.



The Story of a Marriage by Andrew Sean Greer


“Holland and I had talked about our friends and our childhoods and movies and books and politics—we had agreed and disagreed and had our fights and merry moments over a beer—but I think it’s fair to say we had never spoken honestly in all ours lives.” This quote from A Story of a Marriage by Andrew Sean Greer prettily sums up the story’s central conflict. The narrator, Pearlie a young mother and wife to her high school sweetheart, Holland grapples with her marriage in 1950’s San Francisco. She says, “I loved you like a field on fire,” in reference to Holland, and yet her marriage and commitments are tested by the appearance of a dapper stranger.

It does the novel a disservice to reveal any more about the plot, as its secrets are revealed in well timed waves. In fact the book’s only draw back is its brevity as its simple prose endears readers page by page. It’s an unconventional love story written with graceful restraint and vibrant characters. The Story of a Marriage is as perfect a novel as any I've read.

April 19, 2009

Lady of Milkweed Manor by Julie Klassen

I do not remember how I stumbled upon Lady of Milkweed Manor by Julie Klassen, but I am so glad that I did. It is a heart-wrenching (though not unbearably so) and heart-warming story of an unwed mother set in England during the early 1800's. It was quite the page-turner. This is not because it is suspenseful really but because I really liked the main character, Charlotte Lamb, and wanted to know what became of her.

It is a story of womanly issues (childbirth, breastfeeding, a mother's sacrifice) so I doubt many men would like the book. On the other hand, being an ex-doula and current childbirth educator, it was right up my alley. It was fascinating to see how far we have come in many ways. It was refreshing to read a tale of maternal sacrifice when so often children are treated as talking pets in our society.

Honor and romance also figure into the story. It pits the flattery and eye-lash batting kind against the thoughtful and subtler kind. It shows love as doing what is best for the other person. It shows marriage as a commitment and a tender thing between a man and a woman.

This book also made me think about the balance between God's grace and a world of consequences. It is a thought provoking book in many respects, yet it is not preachy.

I gladly give this book 5 stars.



The Amber Room by Steve Berry

I could have sworn I'd reviewed The Romanov Prophecy by Berry, but it doesn't come up in the search tool.

"But Marie," you may be asking, "why on earth are you reading Steve Berry's books? You thought The Templar Legacy sucked!"

Yes I did. And I still do. Some of you may remember I even wrote a spoof of this type of novel on my blog. But I am a sucker for History, and while Berry may be a bad novelist, his History lessons are pretty good, if not a tad biased and misguided as we saw in The Templar Legacy.

I picked up The Romanov Prophecy a couple months ago because I have a weakness for anything Romanov. It was good, much better than The Templar Legacy, actually almost believable. In fact I'd give it five stars. And I found out when I read The Last Tsarina by Carolly Erickson that his research was just about flawless. So when I saw The Amber Room, another Romanov-related piece, I grabbed it.

Blah.

Turns out The Amber Room was Berry's first novel, and it shows. It would be a great book for someone who just wants the thrill of an adventure novel with car chases and shoot-outs and heroes dangling from precipices, but I'm really not into all that stuff. I want good research, a compelling story, believable characters, and intrigue. The only one of these that exists in this novel is the research.

All of Berry's female characters in this book are identical. Same woman, different hair color and a name change. They're all aggressive bombshell Bond Girls that treat men the way men usually treat women in these books. And Berry's men like it. The men are more varied, but they're all a bunch of cold fish, with the exception of bad guy Christian Knoll. He's the only character I managed to like. I got the idea that Berry liked him too, and that while he worked really hard to make Knoll appear bad, he couldn't help but pour all of his energy into developing that one character.

One thing Berry did in this book that was simply unbearable was to constantly repeat himself. There are three or four different sets of people looking for the same thing, and they each come across the same things at different times, and each time they do he must explain the thing all over again. It's like visiting a senile relative that can't remember that they already told you last time about the night nurse stealing their memory foam slippers. And the time before that. And the time before that.

But the worst crime Berry committed in this book is that he somehow made the story of an epic missing treasure boring. I was fascinated by the Amber Room before I read this book, now the very name makes me yawn.

But if you just want some good old fashioned Thomas Crown art action, you may love this book.

April 18, 2009

Fight Club by Chuck Palahniuk

You've probably seen the movie, and possibly didn't even realize it was based on a book. I know I didn't. As in most book-to-movie situations, this book gives a lot of insight into characters and situations that simply aren't possible to express in film. I'll get to that in a minute.

Fight Club is the story of two male friends who start a club that basically involves beating the crap out of each other. The club is oddly successful and begins to branch out nationally, meeting in bars and basements. But as the men get accustomed to fighting they want more, and they progress to acts of domestic terrorism. Can they be stopped? Can the founders cope with the monster they've created?

There's so much more to it, but to bring it up would ruin the surprise elements. If you've seen the movie you have an idea of what I mean.

One of the most interesting aspects of reading this book for me was that the character of Marla Singer is so clearly Helena Bonham-Carter. I always thought Carter had been an odd choice for that role, having come from her background of Historical romance flicks, but it seems almost as though the character was written with her in mind.

Now for what the film doesn't explain that the book does. The narrator, whose name is never given, is an insomniac. He goes to a doctor for relief and is basically blown off. The doctor tells him that losing sleep is no big deal, if he wants to know what real trouble is like he should drop in at a cancer support group. So he does, and finds that somehow the support the group provides allows him to sleep. So he goes to a different one every night of the week, for two years. Then he meets Tyler, who changes everything by saying one night, "I want you to hit me as hard as you can." And Fight Club is born.

Fight Club is not a mindless sport club. Although the premise is simple, it provides for masses of men what the support groups provided for the narrator. Men who are powerless, stuck in dead end lives, are empowered and gain a vitality they never knew before. Fight Club fills a huge void.

I don't remember how the film ended, but the book ends beautifully, the narrator having discovered the truth about his friend and the trap he is caught in. But is this discovery an escape or a bigger trap?

Some quotes:

May I never be complete. May I never be content. May I never be perfect. Deliver me, Tyler, from being perfect and complete.

After a night in fight club, everything in the real world gets the volume turned down. Nothing can piss you off. Your word is law, and if other people break that law or question you, even that doesn't piss you off.

You aren't alive anywhere like you're alive at fight club.... Fight club isn't about winning or losing fights. Fight club isn't about words. You see a guy come to fight club for the first time, and his ass is a loaf of white bread. You see this same guy here six months later, and he looks carved out of wood. This guy trusts himself to handle anything. There's grunting and noise at fight club like at the gym, but fight club isn't about looking good. There's hysterical shouting in tongues like at church, and when you wake up Sunday afternoon you feel saved.

For thousands of years, human beings had screwed up and trashed and crapped on this planet, and now history expected me to clean up after everyone. I have to wash out and flatten my soup cans. And account for every drop of used motor oil. And I have to foot the bill for nuclear waste and buried gasoline tanks and landfilled toxic sludge dumped a generation before I was born.

I see the strongest and the smartest men who have ever lived... and these men are pumping gas and waiting tables.

We don't have a great war in our generation, or a great depression, but we do, we have a great war of the spirit. We have a great revolution against the culture. The great depression is our lives. We have a spiritual depression.

"What you have to understand, is your father was your model for God. If you're male and you're Christian and living in America, your father is your model for God. And if you never know your father, if your father bails out and dies or is never at home, what do you believe about God?"

"We are the middle children of history, raised by television to believe that someday we'll be millionaires and movie stars and rock stars, but we won't. And we're just learning this fact. So don't fuck with us."


April 16, 2009

The Thirteenth Tale - Diane Setterfield

I read The Thirteenth Tale by Diane Setterfield and i couldn't put it down. It's the story of a young women who is asked to meet with a mysterious dying author with a dark past. (*note this book contains content that some readers may find offensive) It was the writing that captivated me, i just found her to have such a great way with words, here are some of my favourite passages:

1. - There is something about words. In expert hand, manipulated deftly, they take you prisoner. Wind themselves around your limbs like spider silk, and when you are so enthralled you cannot move, they pierce your skin, enter your blood, numb your thoughts. Inside you they work their magic.

2. - People disappear when they die. Their voice, their laughter, the warmth of their breath. Their flesh. Eventually their bones. All living memory of them ceases. This is both dreadful and natural. Yet for some there is an exception to this annihilation. For in the books they write they continue to exist.

3. - 'Politeness. Now there's a poor man's virtue if ever there was one. What's so admirable about inoffensiveness, I should like to know? After all, it's easily achieved. One needs no particular talent to be polite. On the contrary, being nice is what's left when you've failed at everything else. People with ambition don't give a damn what other people think about them. I hardly suppose Wagner lost sleep worrying whether he'd hurt someone's feelings. But then he was a genius.'

4. - The young people at the lakeside made a pretty picture from a distance in their summer frocks and white shirts. The glasses they held were filled with a liquid that sparkled in the sunlight and the grass at their feet looked soft enough to go barefoot. In reality, the picnickers were sweltering beneath their clothes, the champagne was warm, and if anyone had thought to take their shoes off they would have had to walk through goose droppings.

5. - I made a resolution to telephone my mother the next day, but it was a safe resolution; no one can hold you to a decision made in the middle of the night.

6. - 'Do you believe in ghosts, Margaret?"
Do I believe in ghosts? What could Isay? I nodded.
Sastisfied, Miss Winter sat back in her chair, and I had the not unfamiliar impression of having given away more than I thought.

7. - But those were private tears, and not for this man. The tears I gratified him with were fake ones. Ones to set off my green eyes the way diamonds set off emeralds. And it worked. If you dazzle a man with green eyes, he will be so hypnotized that he won't notice there is someone inside the eyes spying on him.

8. - 'You are at liberty to say nothing if that is what you want. But silence is not a natural environment for stories. They need words. Without them they grow pale, sicken and die. And then they haunt you.' Her eyes swivelled back to me. 'Believe me, Margaret. I know.'

9. - It was the warmth of her hand that persuaded me she could hear me. It was the warmth in her hand that brought all the words into my chest, falling over each other in their impatience to fly into Emmeline's ear.

10. - 'I am human. Like all humans, I do not remember my birth. By the time we wake up to ourselves, we are little children, and our advent is something that happened an eternity ago, at the beginning of time.'

11. - I should not have been surprised at the extent of Adeline's hatred. I knew how ugly her anger could be, had witnessed the lengths she might go to, I could scarcely believe it.

12. - I feel my heart die. What have I done? Have I...? Is it possible that...?
I cannot bear to know.
I cannot bear not to know.

13. - I did not see the wolf when he came. I did not hear him. There was only this: a little before dawn i became aware of a hush, and I realized that the only breathing to be heard in the room was my own.

Ultimatum by Matthew Glass

In Ultimatum, Matthew Glass, puts together an eerily possible futuristic scenario. President elect in 2032, Joseph Benton, discovers the global warming problem he was preparing for is more rapidly approaching then he’s prepared for. Political maneuvering ensues.

The action does stall at times giving way to much dialogue and consequential discussion. However, Glasses writing is crisp and the conclusion is dramatic as could be desired. The fear this novel conjures is in its realism. Though disturbing, Ultimatum is not a traditional thriller as expected, but more of a look at cause and effect politics and international policy which to some may be even scarier. Those interested in political and environmental intrigue will surely enjoy this debut.


April 15, 2009

The Giver by Lois Lowry

A couple weeks ago on SoulPancake.com, people posted the five books they thought should be required reading. This book came up on a lot of lists, and I'd never heard of it, so I thought I'd give it a read. A lot of people said it was required reading in school, so I was doubly surprised I'd never heard of it. When I picked it up I found out why. It was published in 1993, I graduated in '94. Har har.

This book is sort of Diet Ayn Rand. Yet another negative utopia scenario. In fact it was basically Anthem for teenagers. Kid grows up in a communal society and realizes there's more to life, breaks free. Same old same old. There are some things that some people might call "Magical Realism," but I personally hate that phrase. Otherwise, that's all it was. I might have liked this book more if I'd never read Anthem. I can see why it's popular, I can see why schools use it, it's like a stepping stone to meatier things. I may use it myself one day in my homeschooling endeavors. But if you've already read Ayn Rand or 1984 or anything like that, it's redundant in my opinion.

April 14, 2009

Fall on Your Knees by Ann-Marie MacDonald

This is the story of a family in Nova Scotia during the Great War and the Depression. A very strange family. On the front of the book there is a quote that compares it to something by John Irving. When I saw that, I thought to myself, "that means there's incest." Then I dismissed that thought and decided it must refer to something else. But I turned out to be right.

The thing is, when John Irving writes about incest, as he almost always does, he writes it in such a way as to almost make it seem understandable, forgivable. I think MacDonald did try to do that, owing to the tone of humor and nonchalance she adopts when addressing that situation, but she failed. It was awkward, reading this situation and getting the idea that you're just supposed to be okay with it all. There's also a lesbian aspect, and that goes over much better than the incest did.

Otherwise it was interesting reading. Not impossible to put down, not life changing, not something I'd read again, but interesting.


April 13, 2009

gods behaving badly by Marie Phillips

Well I think I have finally got the Greek gods sorted out. Marie Phillips has cleverly lodged them in a decrepit home in London where they quarrel amongst themselves, idle and unheeded. Then Ms. Phillips was nice enough to keep an eye on them and jot down their comings-and-goings and share them all in Gods Behaving Badly

The mighty have indeed fallen and are short on funds, short on vim & vigor, and not at all prepared when Apollo -- in a fit of pique -- puts out the sun. A quick trip to the underworld should set things aright, or maybe not. I'm certainly not going to tell.

Gods Behaving Badly is a bit risque, after all it features Aphrodite and Apollo and all their assorted cousin/siblings, and is very very amusing. The mortals we meet are all much nicer than most of the gods, as illustrated here in one of my favorite passages, an exchange between the morally vacuous Apollo and Neil, a basic dude:
"You do not apologize because you feel guilty and you want the feeling to go away," said Neil.
"You don't?" said Apollo.
"No, You apologize because you feel guilty and that guilt is how you know that you that you've done something wrong. And then you want to make amends. You don't apologize because you want to make yourself feel better. You apologize because you want to make the other person feel better."
"But why should I want to make you feel better?" said Apollo [ . . . ] "I couldn't care less how you feel."
"Yes, I think I gathered that."
The book is heretical on many levels, so should not be read as a source of religious instruction but if you have never straightened out the Greek pantheon, this is a fun way to go about it. However, if you tend towards primness, you will want to skip chapter 2. It's not THAT bad, but it is, well, it is Apollo and Aphrodite, doing what they do best.


~Suzanne

April 10, 2009

The Deuteronomy Project by Richard B. Couser

The Deuteronomy Project by Richard B. Couser follows two men as they study the book of Deuteronomy together. The main character Chris, is a lawyer and family man, who feels a lack of purpose in his life and the Bible studies he has been using are boring him. He is looking for a deeper meaning in the Word of God. Enter Hal. Hal is a retired pastor who mentors Chris in the study of Deuteronomy.

The book itself is excellent. The information given is wonderful. It is a Bible study in fiction form. I actually learned a lot. The characters are interesting. It fascinating to read how events in their lives help to create a better understanding of verses. Even though the book is fiction, it felt real.

My only complaint about The Deuteronomy Project is that it is slow moving and long. It is just over 500 pages and includes approximately 50 pages of Bible study questions to follow along with.

Overall very happy with the book and would recommend it to others.

April 9, 2009

Spring Growth

Tis the season of new growth, isn't it? Well, the Book Nook is growing, too!

Applied Christianity found out about us through Wickle and is joining our ranks! She's a wife and mother of 2 from Texas. Her personal blog is Christianity Lived Out. Welcome, AC!

As always, if you are interested in become a Book Nook reviewer, email me (Ronnica) at thereaderscircle (at) gmail (dot) com. There's no requirement to be a reviewer, other than to want to share the books you've loved or hated!

April 7, 2009

The Witch of Portobello by Paulo Coelho

I've been a big fan of Paulo Coelho for years. He doesn't just write for entertainment or money, his writing is an outreach of sorts. He believes he knows things that others would be happier for knowing, and wants to share it. In fact he once made his publishers angry by making several of his books available free in digital form via his website. But perhaps "happier" is not the right word for his endeavors. And that's what this book is about. In part. He doesn't want to comfort or placate, he doesn't want us to be content, he wants to provoke us into action. To stop sitting around and pursue.

All of Coelho's books are in the spirit of learning. His most famous is The Alchemist, about the nature of dreams (both the night kind and the goal kind) and the following thereof. Veronika Decides to Die is about making the decision to live, really live, and The Fifth Mountain is about the life of one of the Old Testament's greatest prophets as well as about the power of written language. Some people call Coelho "New Agey," and he definitely can be that, but the things he writes about tend to be very universal. He has a blog, and his blog is extremely New Agey. Some of his books are definitely more New Agey than others. In fact he has hinted that he is heavily influenced by Carlos Castaneda, who wrote some very creepy books about practicing witchcraft and the occult in Mexico.

The only thing that bothers me about Coelho is that I believe he tends to oversimplify. It seems like he thinks that oversimplification is necessary to find the root of truth. That may be true for some things, or for some people, but a lot of the time it's just not necessary. It can actually make things seem more complicated then they really are.

The Witch of Portobello is about a woman who is on a quest to find what she calls the Vertex, a bright light or a presence she has felt. As a Christian I would call this the presence of God, which doesn't require a quest, but I indulged. She starts out as a very devout Catholic, but the church turns her away when she most needs it, so she goes looking elsewhere. Her quest takes her into Paganism and Mother worship and other practises.

Coelho uses this woman's quest as a device to (a) teach us about Gaia, or Mother Earth, as the feminine counterpart to God and (b) suggest that the Christian church is just a passing phase and in the next century we'll all be druids again.

Don't get excited yet, just digest that and let me continue.

In Coelho's other writings, I found many reasons to respect his wisdom. But in this book, he simply jumps to conclusions, doesn't think things through, and shows that he has a failing, a compromised bias against Christianity, a bias that he can't seem to substantiate. He probably could substantiate it if he tried harder, but he simply built on current unfounded prejudices. And he shows a huge lack of understanding of the spirituality of the Christian faith, which surprised me, because in his previous books he showed an affinity to Christianity.

His characters express an amazement that people choose to follow a male God, a distant God who simply wants to dictate rules and provide the bare necessities. With Gaia, on the other hand, there are no rules. No processes, only actions. They don't understand why people can't just love the earth under their feet, just love love, just believe. Believe in what he doesn't say, just believe.

Well, I'll tell you why they can't be satisfied with dirt and trees. And I'm not preaching or proselytising, just answering his questions in a scholarly sense. In the first place, they're wrong. God isn't a dictator, he's a heavenly father. But he's a mother too. I could cite numerous Bible verses on the subject as well as instances from my own life. He's a trinity, a family in one. He both provides and nurtures. And as any parent knows (I don't believe Coelho is a parent, I could be wrong), children crave rules. Without guidelines they are afraid and uncertain of their parents' love. Beyond that, there are many things the Earth does not provide. Yes it is physically present. But we need more than physical presence. We need to know there is something more, something beyond ourselves, something that will be there when we pass, something that can help as and guide us and teach us. Gaia does not teach. Gaia was born of chaos. She has no rules, she provides no comfort. She's beautiful, she's compelling, she's a force inside of us; in the pull of the moon and our own bodies and human relationships. But the only love she offers is a 6' hole in the ground. And that's not very satisfactory as far as I'm concerned.

Some quotes from the very first page:

"No one sacrifices the most important thing she possesses: love." Oh yes she does, in fact I think we all have. Parents especially sacrifice love every day.

"No one places her dreams in the hands of those who might destroy them." Heck yeah they do. We all do. We all trust people with our dreams and are let down. In fact a dream has to be crushed repeatedly before it can be brought about, or it wouldn't be a dream. Sometimes we crush our dreams ourselves, but most often we let others do it for us.

The church Coelho depicts in this book reminds me of that hate filled "Baptist" church that's always picketing funerals on the news. His church is an uneducated stew of zealots who care only about rules and nothing about God's love or compassion. And he expresses the belief that all Christian churches are this way. He is extremely wrong.

All that aside, my mediocre rating of this book is not due to his beliefs, but due to the fact that the story is weak, the teachings oversimplified, and his arguments weak. I highly recommend the other Coelho books I mentioned, but this one was a disappointment.



April 6, 2009

A Fortunate Age by Joanna Smith Rakoff



A Fortunate Age by Joanna Smith Rakoff, approaches a group of post-graduate Gen-Xers as they begin their adult lives tackling friendship, coupling, love and sex. Rackoff is a tactical author who employs fresh methods of story telling to establish excitement and interest. For example, instead of getting a narrative of events central to the story, we get character reactions to some of these events, as the group tries to relate major events to how they may affect their own lives. To accomplish this we get a lost of tangents and back story which then clarifies character’s motive and thought processes. Huge plot developments are not even mentioned—only inferred later in the story. Such devices combine ensuring a dramatic story arc for all of the characters, and a book that reads as more of complex study of characters then a typical novel. Readers will literarily climb into Rakoff’s group and the minds of its members. Overall, Rakoff delivers a strong and highly literary debut. The layered examination of New York culture during the time period reads like a modernized Wharton.


April 3, 2009

Summit Avenue by Mary Sharratt

This is the story of a young German immigrant, Kathrin, who comes to the U.S. just before WWI. She grew up in the Black Forest, a place no one can possibly think of without imagining all sorts of magic and enchantment. Her first two years in Minneapolis she shares a room with her worldly cousin Lotte and works in a flour mill. But then she is hired by a wealthy widow, Violet, to translate German fairy tales for a book she is writing. Violet lives in a beautiful castle-like mansion, complete with turreted towers, stone covered with ivy, and a walled garden. Violet takes Kathrin under her wing and shares with her the Russian fairy tales she learned growing up. Kathrin finds these tales and their framework framing her own life.

The first 88 pages of this book were absolutely magical. Sharratt took the things I loved about my favorite childhood books (A Little Princess, The Secret Garden, etc.) and turned them into a story for grown-ups. I could just see myself sitting in a garden on a spring sunset, eating soft cheese with fruit and drinking wine, listening to the insects and pondering the wonder of life spread out before me. I hated to put the book down and go to sleep because it was just so delicious.

But then it turned into a lesbian romance.

Not that there's anything wrong with that. But it just ruined it for me. Not because of the lesbian stuff inherently, but because that turn of events was just so freaking typical of modern literature that it was an annoyance and a disappointment. It could have been a great book, the same book, without that. But Sharratt just couldn't help herself.

I really liked the way this book was organized. It was set up to mimic Violet's fairy tale studies. Kathrin starts out as the Maiden, the Virgin, her finger poised just over the spindle of the spinning wheel, bursting with adventure and potential. Violet writes about how in fairy tales, a heroine is only a heroine at this point of her life. Once she surrenders to marriage and motherhood she is no longer her own, and goes into a sort of dormancy, until her children are grown and she is widowed. Then she is the Crone, the sorceress, the enchantress, there to help or to terrify as she chooses, a heroine again, but never to the same degree as when she was a maiden. Kathrin goes through these stages as well, and Violet's theories are reflected in her life.

I really loved this book, except for the lesbian bit. Why oh why did she have to do that???

Purple Hibiscus by Chimamanda Ngozi Adichie

Purple Hibiscus is a story told by a Nigerian teenage girl, Kimbili. Kimbili's family is wealthy, and her father is known for his generosity and devoutness to the Catholic Church throughout their community. But the insights of Kimbili, her brother, and her mother into the true character of the man of the house are not shared with outsiders until she and her brother visit their aunt and cousins. Kimbili struggles with relating to her cousins in part because their impression of her as a spoiled, rich kid who looks down on them is ridiculously off base.

Though there are some glimpses at the political upheavel in the country that remind you that this story takes place in Nigeria, it really could have taken place anywhere. It's a story about family loyalties and divisions, hypocrisy and proven faith, reservedness and finding your true voice. Kimbili struggles with her great desire to please her father, who in attempting to help his family does them much harm.

If you enjoy books about families or coming of age, you'll enjoy this book. It's a quick read that's difficult to put down.

April 2, 2009

It Can't Happen Here by Sinclair Lewis

This book is what is referred to as a "negative utopia," a futuristic (futuristic being a very relative term here) depiction of a world gone wrong, usually in a political sense.

This book was actually written in the early 30's during the Great Depression, and takes place in the late 30's. During this time the ideas of Socialism were looking pretty good to a lot of people who were unable to find work or to afford the simplest utilities. The book assumes that it is a given that the government will have to take control of any corporation that provides something that effects all people, such as utilities. The heros are Liberals, the bad guys are conservatives that want a more corporate state.

The funny thing about political extremism is that if you go too far to one side, you'll actually find yourself coming out on the opposite end. It's not really a scale, it's more like a circle. I've seen this with my husband, who's so right-wing that his right-wing desires end up being the very things the left wing advocates, though he will never admit it. They want the same things for different reasons. Sinclair doesn't himself make this connection, but unwittingly demonstrates it in this book.

This book is meant to show how a horrible dictatorship could come about even in America, in a place where such a thing seems impossible. In their economic crisis, the Americans in this book elect Buzz Windrip because he promises that every family will receive $5,000 a year (probably about equivalent to $40k a year now) no matter what. He promises to eliminate unemployment and crime and create a smaller government. And so he's elected. But he eliminates unemployment by sending everyone to work camps, and crime by rounding up everyone even suspected of ever having committed a crime and having them shot. He abolishes all political parties and creates his own. He creates smaller government by abolishing statehood and setting up six large disctricts run by tyrranical commissioners. In the meantime detractors are killed or sent to concentration camps. A new Underground Railroad is established to send refugees to Canada.

It seems like Sinclair took elements of Soviet Russia (although some of his heros are communists) and Nazi Germany (althought this was pre-WWII, the Nazis were in power when the novel was written) and smooshed them together to show how such a regime could happen in the USA. A lot of the situation was really unique to that time period though and truly could not happen now, such as the media being limited to radio and newsprint and information therefore easily repressed or delayed.

It was hard to get into. It didn't actually get interesting until the last third or so, and had an open ending. It was funny in some places and horribly boring in others, but that's probably because a lot of the language and situations were familiar to that time and not to me.

April 1, 2009

Pride and Prejudice and Zombies by Jane Austen and Seth Grahame-Smith


The Pride and Prejudice we all know has been re-imagined. England is over run with brain lusting Zombies. Elizabeth and her sisters are trained and practiced in the deadly art of Zombie slaying. Elizabeth’s best friend has been stricken with the “strange plague”. And a true gentleman beheads the Zombies for his lady, so that she will not soil her dress.

Without offending die hard Jane Austen fans, maybe Pride and Prejudice should have always had a Zombie element. The Zombies contrast our characters so nicely that they manage to make the sarcasm funnier, the villains more disgusting, and the story even more dramatic. It’s like classic literature in high definition. For instance, when propping Lydia, Mrs. Bennett or Wickham next to hordes of Zombies, the reader does briefly wonder who is viler.

Seth Grahame-Smith’s ingenious idea for a lethal mix of classic Austen text with Zombie references and battles spawns pure entertainment. This re-telling is obviously deliciously over the top. Here’s a taste: “But the presence of a woman who had slain ninety dreadfuls with nothing more than a rain soaked envelope was an intimidating prospect indeed”. And my favorite quote, “Elizabeth and Darcy happened upon a herd of unmentionables…crawling on their hands and knees, biting into ripe heads of cauliflower, which they had mistaken for stray brains”. This edition also contains illustrations detailing the action and adding to its charming ludicrousness.

I plan on gifting this to everyone. What a sneaky way to get my teenage brother to appreciate some classic literature. Literary types and Zombie lovers alike should appreciate the spirit of this reinvention, if they don’t relish every word. I have never read anything like it, so I’m officially begging for a series of classic literature injected with Zombie mayhem.

I'm also offering a brand new copy to one lucky reader. Please leave a comment by April 11th (with a distinguishable email) to be entered.

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...
Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...